See what drives us forward from our team to our values.

Our consultative approach results in the right solution every time.

Our leadership team is behind our solutions and services.

Learn about our open positions and how to join our team.

Reach out to a vehicle reimbursement expert or a support member.

mBurse provides customized vehicle reimbursement solutions & mileage apps you need to support your organization's mobile employees.

Customized vehicle reimbursement programs that provide equitable payments regardless of mileage and costs.

Ensure the safety of your organization & employees with insurance verification, MVR checks, the Safe Driver Program, and more.

Provide employees with the most flexible and customizable mileage tracking app that protects their privacy.

mBurse technology streamlines the reporting and approval process. You can manage your mileage approvals and reporting at your fingertips.

See how our solutions have created value for our clients.

Learn about our client's journey and road map to success with mBurse services.

All the tools you need to help evaluate your existing program and compare them to easy tax-free options.

Extensive research and visual guides on vehicle reimbursement solutions, mileage tracking, car allowance, risk, FAVR etc.

The most comprehensive guides on vehicle reimbursements, mileage tracking, and designing the best vehicle reimbursement solutions.

Find out how much you can save using our solutions.

Insights, updates, and the latest on vehicle reimbursements.

Why an Equal Car Allowance Is Not an Equitable Car Allowance

Written by mBurse Team Member   |   Mar 4, 2024 7:00:00 AM

When an organization pays a car allowance, it is typical to pay the same amount to all employees who drive for the company. But a more equitable approach can immediately improve any organization's car allowance policy.

How to Improve Your Car Allowance with an Equitable Approach

It is no secret that everyone wants to be treated fairly. In theory, paying an equal car allowance to all employees is a fair approach. Everyone gets treated equally in terms of the payment amount. But when you look into it, this is not a fair arrangement for everyone.

Different employees working for the same company will experience differing levels of expense associated with their use of a personal vehicle for work. This simple fact is what makes an equal car allowance unfair.

Calculate your optimal 2024 car allowance (free)

Equal vs. equitable car allowances

Say you have two sales reps who work in different states, one in a coastal metropolis with a high cost of living, the other in a midwestern or southern state with much lower costs. Even if those two workers drive the same number of miles per month, the one in the more expensive location will experience higher costs.

The same kind of inequality in costs can emerge when one rep services locations that are close together and the other racks up mileage traveling between widespread destinations. 

When an equal payment is applied to these unequal costs, one of the employees comes out on the wrong end of the calculation. If you pay a $600/month allowance to an employee who averages $550/month in costs and to an employee who averages $650/month in costs, that is an inequitable arrangement. Yet that is exactly what happens when a car allowance policy does not take into account location based differences in costs.

Ways to improve an inequitable car allowance policy

The keys to improving an inequitable car allowance are data, flexibility, and non-taxation. Here's how adjustments to each aspect of your policy can bring immediate improvements to the fairness of your program.

1. Use data to calculate appropriate car allowance amounts.

Very few organizations base their car allowances on vehicle expense data. Most use a number derived from a competitor or based on whatever the amount was years ago when the policy was created – possibly adjusted for inflation, but maybe not.

Data related to the various kinds of costs associated with vehicle use for business can be use to determine an appropriate car allowance amount for employees working in different locations. Gas prices look very different in California than in Texas. Insurance rates in Louisiana are higher than in Ohio. Auto depreciation, though it varies less from state to state, should be factored into a fair car allowance.

In order to deliver an equitable car allowance to all employees, that allowance should be based on localized vehicle expense data. Yes, this is more complicated than picking a reasonable number and sticking with it. But providing a data-derived allowance will send a strong message to employees that they are valued. And once instituted, this data-based policy will remain a solid basis for future adjustments.

2. Embrace flexibility with car allowance amounts.

The hardest part of moving to a data-driven, equitable car allowance policy is having to pay different amounts to different employees. It adds a wrinkle into benefits calculations. But organizations already pay different salaries to different employees depending on the nature of their job, their experience level, and what they add to the organization. 

The nice thing about a data-based car allowance is that, unlike a salary, it is not a negotiable amount. Instead, the allowance is based on real-world evidence of what it will cost each employee to operate a personal vehicle for work purposes.

Algorithms exist that can calculate an appropriate allowance amount for each employee, based on location and territory size (i.e. mileage required). You feed the location-based data in for a theoretical vehicle that makes reasonable sense, and you get a number that will work for that employee. Computer programs can do the work for you – you just have to get partnered with the right program.

3. Eliminate taxes on the car allowance to fund the new policy.

Because a standard car allowance is not based on an IRS-approved accounting method to calculating business costs, you have to pay taxes on the full allowance amount. Switching to a data-based allowance that pays different amounts to different workers will enable you to go tax-free.

Going tax-free will not only save the organization money but will also enable you to fund the changes to your program. Obtaining data and the appropriate software to calculate equitable car allowances will cost money. But the investment will easily be covered by the elimination of tax waste.

Most car allowances are reduced by as much as 30-40% due to federal and state taxes. The employer has to pay taxes on the allowance as well because of FICA/Medicare. That's a huge amount of money that can be reinvested into a better program that treats employees more fairly and removes the guesswork from remuneration.

Choosing a new car allowance policy partner

To improve a car allowance policy, it helps to work with an expert. mBurse has FAVR car allowance programs designed to produce the results outlined in this post. To learn more about our client-centered, consultative approach, contact mBurse today. 

Or get started with a FAVR plan comparison below.

Compare your vehicle program to a FAVR Plan

 

 

Subscribe by email to
receive updates