Why the IRS Mileage Rate is Terrible for Businesses

Written by mBurse Team Member Mar 12, 2018 3:27:12 PM

If your company has employees that drive a personal vehicle for business, you probably use the IRS mileage rate to reimburse expenses. If so, you are using the wrong tool for the task, and your company is exposed to uncontrollable costs and unnecessary risks. Similarly, if your company is considering a change to the IRS rate, there are some risks you should evaluate before making the change.

Many people do not know that:

  1. The IRS mileage rate is a tax tool for individual taxpayers—not a business reimbursement tool—and will over-reimburse high mileage travelers and under-reimburse low mileage travelers.
  2. If you have any low mileage travelers in a state with an indemnification labor code, then you are potentially exposed to labor code violations and lawsuits.
  3. Your mileage log will largely determine your costs. 

Let’s take a closer look at each of these potential risk factors.
2019 Mileage Reimbursement Rates

  1. The IRS mileage rate—a tool for taxes, not reimbursements.

The Standard Mileage Rate, or government rate, is published each year by the IRS as a cents-per-mile guide for individual tax deductions. This mileage rate was designed to help taxpayers estimate and deduct un-reimbursed business vehicle expenses rather than catalog and write off actual expenses. In other words, an individual tax payer can use the government rate to avoid tracking and claiming receipts and instead use a standard rate to calculate the deduction, saving a lot of time. 

Given this intended use of the government mileage rate, does it make sense to use it as a reimbursement rate? The IRS derives this mileage rate from the average cost of owning and operating a motor vehicle across the entire United States over the previous year. Depending on where an employee lives and works, what type of vehicle the employee drives, and how many miles the employee drives, that employee could experience costs well above or well below the average.

Many organizations will use the IRS government rate because it is easy to administer and easy to understand and because they lack the methodology to establish a more accurate rate for their particular employees. But in doing so, they either expose employee income to company expenses, or expose the company to additional costs beyond what the employees actually need.

  1. The IRS standard mileage rate can bring labor code violations—and lawsuits 

If you have employees in states with laws that govern reimbursements, you could be exposed to potential lawsuits. The IRS rate has been universally accepted as the “standard” for reimbursements in states where you are required to indemnify employees for vehicle-related business expenses. For the most part companies accept over-reimbursing high mileage business travelers. However, the low mileage business travelers should cause you concern. If a low mileage business traveler can prove that their expenses exceed their reimbursement, they could file a labor code violation—and if there are enough of these low mileage drivers, this could turn into a class action suit.

If you have employees working in California, you should especially pay attention to this concern. California Labor Code 2802(a) is the strictest reimbursement law in the country and can create headaches for companies paying the standard mileage rate.

  1. With the IRS mileage rate, your mileage log will drive your costs.

The standard mileage rate can get expensive and out of control if you are not using a 21st-century mileage log. The rate is easy calculate, and you would expect a simple mileage log to do the trick. However, it is not that simple.

Microsoft Excel mileage logs seem to be the choice for a lot of companies. These types of mileage logs require not only a separate appointment or call log, but also a process to calculate the mileage. This creates several problems. First, a spreadsheet mileage log requires a significant amount of unproductive time for a simple task. Second, many mobile employees will unfortunately take short cuts to reduce the time required and will estimate mileage. Not only is manual recording prone to errors, but an overstatement of mileage will cost the organization.

Now, there are a quite a few mileage-tracking solutions that integrate with your existing business systems to track mileage—not employees—in an accurate and real time method. Avoiding self-reported mileage logs is a big opportunity to save time, mileage, and money. However, by continuing to allow employees to self-report mileage, you are giving them a blank check for mileage.

Another way to save: switch reimbursement methods
A small mileage tracking upgrade will go a long way to save the company money and time, but changing the type of reimbursement policy will go an even longer way. Implementing an IRS accountable plan that was designed for business vehicle reimbursements instead of for personal tax deductions will significantly reduce costs over time.

The standard mileage rate is really only a good tool for drivers that travel under 5,000 business miles annually. If you are looking for alternatives to the government mileage rate or tools to help you better manage costs and productivity contact mBurse today for a free evaluation.

Benchmark your mileage log

icon of envelope

Subscribe by Email